§E³Ð»¨ ¤Þ¨¥ ªñ¦~¨Ó¡Aõ¾Ç®a¤¦©`¯S¡]Daniel Dennett¡^¡B¥Íª«¾Ç®a¹Dª÷´µ¡]Richard Dawkins¡^¡K¡K µ¥¾ÇªÌ¥D¾Éªº¡u·sµL¯«½×¡v°}Àç¡A¹ï°ò·þ±Ð§å§P¤£¿ò¾l¤O¡A¯S§O¬O°ò·þ±Ðªº³Ð³y½×¡A¥t¤@¤è±¡A¾HªÖ´µ°ò¡]William Dembski¡^¡B¤Ú§Æ¡]Michael Behe¡^¡K.. µ¥°ò·þ®{¾ÇªÌºûÅ@ªº¡u´¼¼z³]p¡v¡A«o¨S¦³¨ü¨ì¾Ç³N¬ÉªÖ©w¡C¤£¹L¡A³o¨Ã«D¬O¾ã´T¹Ïµe¡A¼y©¯ªº¬O¡A°ò·þ±Ð·í¤¤¤´¦³¨ã¦³±R°ª¾Ç³N¦a¦ìªºÅ@±Ð¾ÇªÌ¡A¨Ò¦p¾Ö¦³¯«¾Ç¡Bõ¾ÇÂù³Õ¤h¾Ç¦ìªº¶ðªi¯«¾Ç°|¡]Talbot School of Theology¡^±Ð±Â§J¹p®æ¡]William Lane Craig¡^¡B¸t¥À°|¤j¾Çõ¾Ç±Ð±Â¥¬Äõ®x¥[¡]Alvin Plantinga¡^¡C ¹ï¡u´¼¼z³]p¡v¶á¤§¥H»óªº¤H¡A±`±`°õµÛ¡u´¼¼z³]p½×ªº¤å³¹¤£¯à°÷¦b¦P¦æ¼f½Z¡]peer-review¡^ªº¾Ç³N´Á¥Z¤Wµoªí¡v³o¤@ÂI¡A§åµû³Ð³y½×¤£µn¤j¶®¤§°ó¡B°ò·þ±Ð¤Ï´¼ ¡K¡K¡A¦ý§J¹p®æ»P¥¬Äõ®x¥[ªº¤å³¹³£¬O¦b»á¦³¥÷¶qªº¾Ç³N´Á¥Z¤¤±¥@¡A§Y¨ÏµL¯«½×ªÌ¾ÇªÌ¥v±K¤Ò¡]Quentin Smith¡^¤]©Ó»{¡G¡uµL¯«½×ªÌ»P¤£¥iª¾½×ªÌ¹ï[§J¹p®æ¾Ç»¡]ªº¦^À³¡A¬Û¹ï¨Ó»¡¦³ÂIÁ¡®z¡A¬Æ¦ÜÃø¨£Âܼv¡C¡v[i] ¥j¨å¦t©z½×µý ¦b³o½gµu¤å¤¤¡Aµ§ªÌ·Q¤¶²Ð§J¹p®æªº¥d«n¦t©z½×µý¡]Kalam cosmological argument¡^¡A³o½×µý¨Ã¤£¬O§J¹p®æº³Ð¡A¦b¥j¨åÅ@±Ð¾Ç¤¤³o½×µý¤w¥X²{¹L¡A¡u¥d«n¡v¬Oªü©Ô§B¤å¡A³o¬O§Æþ¤å¡ulogo¡vªºÂ½Ä¶¡A·N«ä¬O¡u¹D²z¡v¡A¥d«n½×µý¬O¥ì´µÄõ±Ð¿Ä¦X¤F§Æþ«ä·Q¡A§J¹p®æ°t¦X²{¥N¬ì¾Ç¡A¦A¥[¤WɧU¤F¤¤¥@¬ö¥ì´µÄõ±Ð¤hªº¤ÀªR¡A±N¥d«n¦t©z½×µýµo´§±o²OºvºÉP¡C·íµM¡A¾Ç³N¬É¤¤¦³¤£¤Ö¤Ï¹ï¥d«n¦t©z½×µýªºÆ[ÂI¡A¤@³¡¤À¬Æ¦Ü¥X¦Û°ò·þ®{¡Aµ§ªÌ±N·|²³æ¦a¤¶²Ð¨ä¤¤¨âÓ½×ÂI¡A¦ý³o¨Ç½×ÂI¦ü¥G¥¼¯à¦³®Ä¦a¤Ï»é¥d«n¦t©z½×µý¡A²¦³º¡Aµ§ªÌ¬Û«H¥d«n¦t©z½×µý»P¸t¸g«H®§¤ñ¸û¤@P¡C ¥j¨åªº°ò·þ±Ð¦t©z½×µý¦Ü¤Ö¦³¨âºØ§Î¦¡¡A²Ä¤@ºØ¬O¤¤¥@¬ö¤Ñ¥D±Ð¯«¾Ç¤j®v¸t¦hº¿´µªü«¶¨º¡]St. Thomas Aquinas¡^ªºª©¥»¡Aªü«¶¨º°Ñ¦Ò¤F§Æþõ¾Ç®a¨È¨½´µ¦h¼w»P¥ì´µÄõ¾ÇªÌ¨Èºû´µ¦w®³¡]Avicenna¡^ªº¾Ç»¡¡A´£¥X¤F¡u¤Z¨Æ¥²¦³²Ä¤@¦]¡v³o·§©À¡A²³æ¦a»¡¡A²´«eªº¦t©z¸U¶H¥²µM¦³«e¦]¡A³o¨Ç«e¦]¤§«eÁÙ¦³«e¦]¡AÄ~Äò°l·¹¤U¥h¡A«K·|§Î¦¨¤F¡uµLË°h¡v¡]infinite regress¡^¡A³oºØ¡uµLË°h¡v¦bÅÞ¿è¤WµLªk¦¨¥ß¡A¦]¦¹¡A¦t©z¥²¦³°_¦]¡C[ii] ²Ä¤GºØ¦t©z½×µý¬O¼w°êõ¾Ç®aµÜ¥¬¥§¯÷¡]Leibniz¡^ªºª©¥»¡AµÜ¥¬¥§¯÷ªº±À½×¡A·½©ó¤@Ӭݦü²³æ¡B«o¤Q¤À²`¶øªº°ÝÃD¡G¡u¬°¤°»ò¡]³o¥@¬É¡^¦³¤@¨ÇªF¦è¦Ó¤£¬O¬Æ»ò¤]¨S¦³¡H¡v¡]Why is there something rather than nothing? ¡^µÜ¥¬¥§¯÷«ü¥X¡G¥ô¦ó¦s¦bªº¨Æª«³£¥²µM¦X²z¦a¦s¦b¡A³o´N¬O©Ò¿×¡u¥R¤À¦X²zì«h¡v¡]Principle of sufficient reason¡^¡C¥Ñ³o¦X²z¦s¦b¡A«K¥i¥H±À½×¥X¦t©z¥²©w¦³³Ð³yªÌ¡B³]pªÌ¡C[iii] ¥d«n¦t©z½×µý §J¹p®æªº¥d«n¦t©z½×µý¤ñ¸û±µªñªü«¶¨ºªºª©¥»¡A¤£¦P¤§³B¡A¬O¥L´©¤Þ¤jÃz¬µ½×¡]Big bang¡^¥hµý©ú¦t©z¦³°_ÂI¡A¨ä±À½×¦p¤U¡G 1. ¥ô¦ó¥Í¦¨ªº¨Æª«¥²¦³°_¦]¡A 2. ¦t©z¬O¥Í¦¨ªº¡A 3. ©Ò¥H¡A¦t©z¥²µM¦³¨ä¦s¦bªº°_¦]¡C[iv] ¬Û«H«Ü¦hŪªÌ³£¼ô±x¤jÃz¬µ½×¡A¦b¦¹§Ú¤£¦A²ÖÂئa¸ÑÄÀ¡A²³æ¦a»¡¡A²{¥N¤Ñ¤å¾Ç®a¬Û«H¦t©z¨Ã«DµL¡A¦t©zªº¦~ÄÖ¤j·§¬O¤@¦Ê¤¤Q»õ¦~¡A¥¦¬O°_·½¦Û¤@Ó¡u©_²§ÂI¡v¡]Singularity¡^¡C¹ï°ò·þ®{¨Ó»¡¡A³o¦t©zªº°_¦]·íµM¬O¤W«Ò¡C §J¹p®æÄ~©Ó¤Fªü«¶¨ºªºÆ[ÂI¡A°íºÙ¡uµLË°h¡v¨Ã¤£¥i¯à¡A¬°¦¹¤§¬G¡A¥L¤Ï¹ï¬f©Ô¹Ï¥D¸q¡C®Ú¾Ú¬f©Ô¹Ï¥D¸q©Ò»¡¡A¦b²´«eªº²{¹ê¥@¬É¤§¤W¡AÁÙ¦³¤@Ó¶W¶Vªº²z©À¥@¬É¡A¦b²{¹ê¥@¬É¤¤©Ò¦³¤£§¹¬üªºªF¦è¡A¦b²z©À¥@¬É¤¤³£·|¦³§¹¬üªºªF¦è¬Û¹ïÀ³¡A¨Ò¦p¥@¬É¤W¨S¦³µ´¹ïªº¶ê§Î¡A¦ý¦b²z©À¥@¬É¤¤¦³¡C¼Æ¾Ç¥]§tµÛ§¹¬ü¥@¬Éªº·§©À¡A¦b¼Æ¾Ç¤¤¦³¡uµL¡vªº·§©À¡A¨º»ò¡A¦Ü¤Ö¡uµL¡v¦b²z©À¤¤¬O¥i¯à¦s¦bªº¡A³o¼Ë¡A®e³\¡u¦t©zµL¡v¤S¦³¦ó¤£§´©O¡H[v] §J¹p®æ«o¤£¥H¬°µM¡A¥L«ü¥X¡G¬f©Ô¹Ï¥D¸q»P°ò·þ±Ðºë¯«¨Ã¤£²Å¦X¡A«ö·Ó¬f©Ô¹Ï¥D¸qªº»¡ªk¡A²z©À¥@¬É¤¤¨º¨Ç§¹¬üªºªF¦è³£¬O¿W¥ß¦s¦bªº¡A¿W¥ß©ó¥@¬É¡B¿W¥ß©ó¤H¡B¬Æ¦Ü¿W¥ß©ó¯«¡A³o¼Ë¡A¯«¨Ã«D¸U¦³¤§¥»¡A¦b³Ð³y®É¥L¤]n°Ñ·Ó¨º¨Ç§¹¬üªºªF¦è¡A¦ý³o¦³ªº³Ð³yªÌ¨Ã¤£¬O°ò·þ±Ðªº¯«¡C§_©w¤F¬f©Ô¹Ï¥D¸q¤§«á¡A§J¹p®æ¥ç³s±a¦a§_©w¤F¡uµLË°h¡v¬O¥i¯à¦s¦bªº¡C[vi] ¤Ï»é¡G¦t©z·´·ÀªÌ °w¹ï§J¹p®æ´©¤Þ¤F¤jÃz¬µ½×¥h¤ä«ù¥d«n¦t©z½×µý¡A¸t¥À°|¤j¾Ç±Ð±Â²¦¤h¡]Brian Pitts¡^´£¥X¤F¨âÂI¤Ï»é¡A[vii] º¥ý¡A¥L»{¬°²{¥Nª«²z¾Ç¥u¬O¤ä«ù¤F¦t©z¬O¦³ªº¡A«o¨S¦³»¡¦t©z¦³°_©lªº¤@¨è¡]first moment¡^¡C³o¬O·¥¨ä½ÆÂøªº°ÝÃD¡Aµ§ªÌ¹Á¸Õ¥H¤@Ó²³æªº¤ñ³ë»¡©ú¡G¤@±ø½u¬O¦³¡A¦Ó¥B¦³°_©lÂI¡A¤@Ó¶ê°é¤]¬O¦³¡A«o¨S¦³°_©lÂI¡C¥HªÅ¶¡¨Ó»¡¡A¦t©zªÅ¶¡¥i¯à¬OºP¦±ªº¡A©Ò¥H¥i¥H¬O¦³¦ÓµL¬É¡A¦b®É¶¡¤W¡A¦t©zªº®É¶¡¥i¥H¬O¦³¡A¦ý¥i¯à¨S¦³°_©l¡C ²¦¤h²Ä¤GÂI¤Ï»é¤ñ¸û®e©ö²z¸Ñ¡A¦Ó¥B¸ò¯«¾Ç¦³¤ñ¸û±K¤ÁªºÃö«Y¡A²¦¤h±Ä¥Î¡uÂkÂÕªk¡v¡]Reductio ad absurdum¡^±À½×¥X¥d«n¦t©z½×µý¤£¦¨¥ß¡A©Ò¿×¡uÂkÂÕªk¡v¡A´N¬O«ö·Ó¹ï¤èªºÅÞ¿è±Àºt¥X¤@Ó¯îÂÕªºµ²½×¡A±q¦Ó¥YÅã¥X¹ï¤èªº¥ß½×¤]¬O¯îÂÕªº¡C²¦¤h»¡¡G 1. °ò©ó¤jÃz¬µ½×©Ò»¡¡A¦t©z¤§¥Í¦¨¦³°_¦]¡A©Ò¥H¥²¦³¦t©z³Ð³yªÌ¡F 2. °ò©ó²{¥N¤Ñ¤å¾Çªºµo²{¡A¦t©z¬PÅé¤]·|·´·À¡A©Ò¥H¥²¦³¦t©z·´·ÀªÌ¡C «áªÌ¬O¯îÂÕªº¡A©Ò¥H«eªÌ¤]¬O¯îÂÕªº¡C²¦¤h«ü¥X¡G¡u°ò·þ±Ð´yz¤W«Ò¬O¥@¬Éªº³Ð³yªÌ¡B«O¦uªÌ¡B±ÏÅ«ªÌ¡A¤W«Ò·|¥þµM©ÎªÌ³vº¥¦a¡B§½³¡¦a·´·À¤@Óª«½è¥@¬É³o·Qªk¡A¦b°ò·þ±Ð¯«¾Çùر¬Oê¦i©Ò«ä©ÎªÌ·¥¨ä¨u¨£ªº¡A¥ÛÀY¡B«Ø¿vª«¡B°Êª«·|¤£®É·´·À¡A¦ý¥LÌÁÙ·|¦s¯d´í·º¡A¦ý¬PÅé·´·À«o¤£¬O³o¼Ë¡C¡v[viii] µ§ªÌ²³æ¦a¥æ¥N¦t©z¬PÅé·´·À¬O¬Æ»ò¤@¦^¨Æ¡A²{¥N¤Ñ¤å¾Ç®aµo²{¤F¶W·s¬P¡]supernova¡^¡B¥Õ¸G¬P¡]white dwarf¡^¡B¶Â¬}µ¥¤ÑÅé»P¤Ñ¤å²{¶H¡C¶W·s¬P¬O¬PÅéÃz¬µ¡A¤Ó¶§¯à°÷©ñ®g¥ú¨~¬O¦]¬°®ÖµõÅܲ£¥Í¯à¶q¡A·í¤@Áû¬P¿U®Æ¯ÓºÉ¤§«á¡A¦Ñ¤Æªº®Ö¤ß«K·|˶ò¡A³o¬PÅé¥~¼h«K·|²£¥Í¥X¶W·s¬P§Î¦¡ªºÃz¬µ¡A¤§«áÅܦ¨¤F¤¤¤l¬P©ÎªÌ¶Â¬}¡C©ÎªÌ¡A¦Ñ¦ºªº¬P¬P·|˶ò¦¨½è¶q·¥¨ä¥¨¤jªº¥Õ¸G¬P¡A¸òµÛµo¥Í«ùÄòªºÃz¬µ¡A³o´N¬O©Ò¿×¡u·s¬P¡v¡]Nova¡^¡C¦Ü©ó¶Â¬}¡A²³©Ò©Pª¾¡A¬O·¥¨ã¯}Ãa¤Oªº¡A¥ô¦óªF¦è¶W¶V¤F¶Â¬}ªº¼¹µõ¦a¥½u¡]Event Horizon¡^¤§«á¡A«K·|³Q§l¶i¶Â¬}ùر¡A¥Ã¤£¶W¥Í¡C¥¿¦p²¦¤h©Ò´yz¡A¦b¬PÅé·´·À¤¤¡A³s´í·º¤]¤£·|¯d¤U¨Ó¡C ¡u·´·À¡v¬O¡u¦A³Ð³y¡v¡H µ§ªÌ»{¬°¡G±Ä¥Î²{¥N¤Ñ¤åª«²z¾Ç¦Ó±À½×¥X¦t©z·´·ÀªÌ¡A³o¨Ã¤£¯îÂÕ¡A¦]¦¹¡A¤£¥i¥H¾Ì¦¹»¡¥d«n¦t©z½×µý¬O¯îÂÕ¡A¬°¤°»ò©O¡HµL¥L¡A¸t¸g¤£¬O¥H³Ð³y½×¶}©l¡A¥H¥½¥@½×µ²§ô¶Ü¡H¥D±i¡u§Æ±æ¯«¾Ç¡v¡]Theology of Hope¡^¼w°ê¯«¾Ç®a²ö¯S°Ò¡]Jürgen Moltmann¡^»{¬°¡G³Ð³y»P¥½¥@¬Û»²¬Û¦¨¡A³Ð³y¬O¤@ºØ«ùÄòªº¹Lµ{¡A¥¦ÁÙ¥¼¶êº¡¡A¶êº¡ªº³Ð³ynµ¥¨ì¥½¥@ªº§ó·s¡]eschatological transformation¡^¤~·|¥X²{¡C[ix] ¨ä¹ê¡A±N¬PÅé·´·À¯Ç¤J¥½¥@½×ªº½dÃ¥¨Ó°Q½×¡A¥¼§K¤Ó¹L¡u¶©«¨ä¨Æ¡v¡A¬PÅé·´·ÀÁÙ¤£ºâ¬O¥@¬É¥½¤é©ÎªÌ¦t©z¥½¤é¡Aµ§ªÌ¥u¬O·Q«ü¥X¡G¤W«Ò¦P®É¬O³Ð³yªÌ»P·´·ÀªÌ¡A»P°ò·þ±Ð«ä·Q¨S¦³½Ä¬ð¡C©ÎªÌ¡A¦t©z§½³¡¦a·´·À¡A¥i¥H¥Î¦a²yªº¦a´ß¬¡°Ê§@¬°Ãþ¤ñ¡A¦a²y¦³¼öÄËÄ˪º¦a¤ß©Mº}¬yªº¤j³°ªO¶ô¡]plate tectonics¡^¡A¦]¦¹¡A¦a²y¤£®É¥X²{¤F¤õ¤sÃzµo¡B¦a¾_¡B®ü¼Sµ¥¡u·´·À©Ê¡vªº¨aÃø¡A¦ý³o¨Ç©Ò¿×¡u·´·À¡v¡A¨ä¹ê¬O¾ãÓ¦a²y¡u«OÅ@¡v»P¡u«¾ã¡vªº¥²¸g¹Lµ{¡C¥Ñ©ó¦a²y¨S¦³¾®©T¡A¬G¦¹²£¥Í¤FºÏ³õ¡A«OÅ@¤F¦a²y¤Wªº¥Í©R¤£¨ü¤Ó¶§·¼Éªº«I®`¡A¹Ü¥ØÄ£²´ªº·¥¥ú¡]Polar light¡^«K¬O¤Ó¶§·¼É»PºÏ³õÀ¿¨¦Ó¹Lªºµ²ªG¡C¦b«¾ã¤è±¡A¤j³°ªO¶ô¦³§U©óºÒ®ðªº´`Àô¡A²Óµß±NºÒ®ð±a¶i¤F²`¼hªºªd¤g¡A¤õ¤s¬¡°Ê±NºÒ®ð¦AÄÀ©ñ¥X¨Ó¡C¤Ý¸Þ¦a»¡¡A¨º¨Ç¦a´ß¬¡°Êªº¡u·´·À¡v¡A¦P®É¬O¡u´`Àô¡v©Î¡u¦A³Ð³y¡v¡C²{¦b¬ì¾Ç®a¹ï¶W·s¬P»P¥Õ¸G¬Pªº¥\¯à©Òª¾¬Æ¤Ö¡A¦ý´N¾ãÅé¦t©z¨Ó¦Ò¼{¡A¨º¨Ç©Ò¿×·´·À¡A¤]¥i¯à»P¦a²y¤W¬Y¨Ç·´·À¬¡°Ê¤@¼Ë¡A¨ã¦³¡u¦A³Ð³y¡vªº·N¸q¡C µ²»y Á`¬A¨Ó»¡¡A§J¹p®æªº¥d«n¦t©z½×µý¤ñ¸û»P¸t¸gªº°T®§¤@P¡A¦ýµ§ªÌ·Q±j½Õ¡G³o¨Ã¤£¯àµ´¹ï¦³®Ä¦aµý©ú¤W«Ò³Ð³y¥@¬É¡C§Y¨Ï¥d«n¦t©z½×µý¦¨¥ß¡A³»¦h¥u¯à»¡¡u¦t©z¥²µM¦³¨ä¦s¦bªº°_¦]¡v¡A¦ý³o°_¦]¤S¬O§_¥²©w¬O¤@Ө㦳¤H®æªº¯«©O¡H¦Ó¥B¡A§Y¨Ï³Ð³yªÌ¬O¤@Ó¤H®æ¯«¡A³o¬O§_¥²©w«D°ò·þ±ÐªºC©MµØ²öÄÝ©O¡H¬G¦¹¡A¥d«n¦t©z½×µý¥u¥i¥HÅã¥Ü¤F³Ð³y½×¥¼¥²»P²{¥N¤Ñ¤åª«²z¾Ç¦³½Ä¬ð¡AÄY®æ¨Ó»¡«o¤£¬O¤@Óµý©ú¡C³Ì²×¡A«H¥õ¥u¯à¶D½Ñ«H¤ß¡A¦ýµL½×¦p¦ó¡A¥d«n¦t©z½×µý¤´µMȱo¥O¤H¹ª»R¡A³o½×µý¦b¤@¬yªº¾Ç³N´Á¥Zµoªí»P°Q½×¡A§åµû°ò·þ±Ð¡u¤Ï´¼¡vªºµL¯«½×ªÌÀ³¸Ó¦A¤T¦Ò¼{¨äµû»ù¬O§_«ê·í¡C ¡@ [i] Quentin Smith, ¡§A big bang cosmological argument for god¡¦s nonexistence¡¦, Faith and Philosophy 9 (1992), 217¡V37. µ§ªÌ½Ķ¤F§J¹p®æ¹ï¥v±K¤Ò§åµûªº¦^À³¡A½Ð°Ñ¦ÒW. L. Craig, ¡§The caused beginning of the universe: A Response to Quentin Smith,¡¨ British Journal for the Philosophy of Science, 44 (1993) 623-639. Trans. by Chong Ho Yu. In Online Chinese Christian Resources. Access http://occr.christiantimes.org.hk/art_0003.htm [ii] J. P. Moreland, ¡§A response to a Platonistic and to a set-theoretic objection to the Kalam cosmological argument,¡¨ Religious Studies 39 (2003), 373¡V390. [iii] µÜ¥¬¥§¯÷ªºµª®×¥i»¡¬O¤@¥Û¤G³¾¡A³o¤£¦ý¦^µª¤F¦t©z°_·½ªº°ÝÃD¡A¤]¸Ñ¶}¤F¡u¯«¸q½×¡v¡]Theodicy¡^ªº¦ºµ²¡A©Ò¿×¡u¯«¸q½×¡vªº°ÝÃD¡A´N¬O¥þ¯à¦Ó·O´dªº¯«¡A¬°¤°»ò®e³\¥@¬É¤W¥Rº¡WÃø¡C¦ý¬JµM²{¦sªº¥@¬É¬O³Ì¦X²zªº¡A¨º»ò³o¥@¬É¬O¡u©Ò¦³¥i¯à¥@¬É¤¤³Ì¦nªº¤@Ó¡v¡]The best of all possible worlds¡^¡A¤£µMªº¸Ü¡A³o¥@¬É·|§óÁV¿|¡CGregory Brown, ¡§Leibniz¡¦s Theodicy and the confluence of worldly goods,¡¨ Journal of History of Philosophy 26 (1988), 571-591. [iv] W. L. Craig, ¡§Creation and big bang cosmology,¡¨ Philosophia Naturalis, 31(1994), 217-224. Trans. by Chong Ho Yu. In Online Chinese Christian Resources. Access http://occr.christiantimes.org.hk/art_0040.htm [v] John Taylor, ¡§Kalam: a swift argument from origins to a first cause?¡¨ Religious Studies, 33 (1997),167-179. [vi] W. L. Criag, ¡§A swift and simple refutation of the Kalam cosmological argument?¡¨ Religious Studies, 33(1999), 57-72. [vii] J. Brian Pitts, ¡§Why the Big Bang Singularity does not help the Kalam Cosmological Argument for Theism?¡¨ British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 59 (2008), 675¡V708. [viii] Pitts, 692-693. [ix] J. Moltmann, God in Creation. (1985) London: SCM Press: London. 2009.5
Navigation
| |||||||